Mitigating the Gender Gap in the Willingness to Compete: Evidence from a Randomized Field Experiment∗
نویسنده
چکیده
The lower willingness of females to compete is extensively documented, and has a wide range of implications including gender gaps in occupational choice, achievement and labor market outcomes. In this paper we evaluate the impact on competitiveness of two randomized interventions that involve (1) targeted education to foster grit, a non-cognitive skill that has been shown to be highly predictive of achievement, (2) exposure to successful female role models. The interventions are implemented in a large sample of elementary schools, and we measure their impact using a dynamic competition task with interim performance feedback. We find that competitiveness is malleable in both girls and boys. Specifically, when children are exposed to a worldview that encourages goalsetting and perseverance, the gender gap in the willingness to compete disappears. Introducing successful female role models to all children, however, does not replicate this effect, as it leads both boys and girls to compete more relative to control group, leaving the gender gap intact. We explore the effect of treatments on self-confidence and the response to performance feedback as a potential mechanism to explain these results. JEL Categories: C91, C93, D03, I28
منابع مشابه
Stress Reactions Cannot Explain the Gender Gap in Willingness to Compete
Women are often less willing than men to compete, even in tasks where there is no gender gap in performance. Also, many people experience competitive contexts as stressful and previous research has documented that men and women sometimes react differently to acute stressors. We use two laboratory experiments to investigate whether factors related to stress can help explain the gender gap in com...
متن کاملHow does the Gender Difference in Willingness to Compete evolve with Experience?
I study how gender differences in willingness to compete evolve over time in response to experience. Participants in a lab experiment perform the same real-effort task over several rounds. In each round, they have to choose between piece-rate remuneration and a winner-takes-all competition. At the end of each round, those who compete get feedback on the competition outcome. The main result is t...
متن کاملMatrilineal Kinship and Gender Differences in Competition*
I examine how kinship systems affect gender differences in willingness to compete among individuals from matrilineal and patrilineal societies in Central Africa. These individuals share a common urban environment today, and they are from nearby areas along the border of the matrilineal belt. Individuals participated in a lab experiment in which they completed a task under piece rate pay, tourna...
متن کاملGender Differences in Willingness to Compete: The Role of Culture and In- stitutions Short Title: Culture and Gender Gaps in Competition
Our Beijing-based laboratory experiment investigated gender differences in competitive choices across different birth-cohorts experiencing during their crucial developmental-age different institutions and social norms. To control for general time trends, we use Taipei counterpart subjects with identical original Confucian traditions. Our findings confirm that exposure to different institutions/...
متن کاملGender Matching and Competitiveness: Experimental Evidence
This paper experimentally investigates if and how people’s competitiveness depends on their own gender and on the gender of people with whom they interact. Participants are given information about the gender of the co-participant they are matched with, they then choose between a tournament or a piece rate payment scheme, and finally perform a real task. As already observed in the literature, we...
متن کامل